FREE SHIPPING ON ORDERS $100+, because we love you.

LIKE IT? GET IT. With our Payment Plans

Hassle Free Returns

Your cart

Your cart is empty

Continue shopping

87 Results

Clear filters
Mud Pie Christmas squeeze toys for kids—Santa, reindeer, and tree characters designed for festive sensory fun and stress relief.
Mud Pie Christmas squeeze toys for kids—Santa, reindeer, and tree characters designed for festive sensory fun and stress relief.
50% off

Mud Pie Christmas Squeeze Toys – Santa, Reindeer, or Christmas Tree

$10.00 $5.00

Fruit of the Spirit Tableware

Fruit of the Spirit Tableware

$9.50

Cottage Door Press storybook for 3-year-olds with red cover, gold accents, and a cut-out number three filled with playful illustrations

A Collection of Stories for 3 Year Olds Book

$15.00

Happy Birthday Ceramic Singing Plate - Blue

Happy Birthday Ceramic Singing Plate - Blue

$25.00

Child's Cross Bracelet - Mud Pie

Child's Cross Bracelet - Mud Pie

$35.00

2 colors
Zorbitz Squish Amal Advent Calendar front cover showing collectible holiday Squish-Amal toys and surprises for Christmas.
Back of Zorbitz Squish Amal Advent Calendar for Christmas with 24 numbered doors and festive Santa’s toy shop design.
46% off

Squish-Amal Advent Calendar – 24 Days of Surprises

$18.50 $10.00

Front view of Warmies Candy Corn Plush with embroidered smiling face and cozy tri-color candy corn design.
Warmies Candy Corn Plush with brown arms and legs, featuring bright yellow, orange, and white color sections and scented

Warmies Candy Corn Plush – Microwaveable Scented Soft Toy

$31.50

1 color
Front view of Warmies Pumpkin Spice Cow plush with soft cream and orange fur, holding pumpkin spice-scented lavender filling.
Close-up of Warmies Pumpkin Spice Cow face with detailed embroidered eyes, muzzle, and soft fur, scented with lavender.

Warmies Pumpkin Spice Cow – Microwavable Plush and Aromatherapy Comfort

$31.50

1 color
Mud Pie holiday lip gloss in Santa and Reindeer shapes—festive, child-safe stocking stuffers with sweet shimmer and twist-off tops.
Mud Pie holiday lip gloss in Santa and Reindeer shapes—festive, child-safe stocking stuffers with sweet shimmer and twist-off tops.
50% off

Mud Pie Christmas Lip Gloss – Santa or Reindeer

$10.00 $5.00

Blow Out The Candles Birthday Book

Blow Out The Candles Birthday Book

$24.50

Mud Pie Oyster Shell Nativity Ornament Set
80% off

Mud Pie Oyster Shell Nativity Ornament Set

$25.00 $5.00

Warmies Woodstock plush toy wearing a blue winter scarf, sitting upright with soft yellow fur and cheerful embroidered smile.
43% off

Warmies Woodstock with Winter Scarf – Cozy Peanuts Plush

$35.00 $20.00

Warmies Cinnamon Latte Cow | Microwavable Plush

Warmies Cinnamon Latte Cow | Microwavable Plush

$31.50

1 color
Mud Pie light-up Christmas baseball caps for kids in Santa or Reindeer designs with cozy fabric and festive LED lights.
Mud Pie light-up Christmas baseball caps for kids in Santa or Reindeer designs with cozy fabric and festive LED lights.
44% off

Mud Pie Light-Up Christmas Baseball Cap – Santa or Reindeer

$18.00 $10.00

Cottage Door Press storybook for 4-year-olds with blue cover, gold details, and a large number four filled with colorful illustrations

A Collection of Stories for 4 Year Olds Book

$15.00

My First Christmas Holiday Wooden Picture Frame Ornament
75% off

My First Christmas Holiday Wooden Picture Frame Ornament

$20.00 $5.00

1 color
University of Kentucky Baby Blanket

University of Kentucky Baby Blanket

$33.00

3 colors
God Calls Me silicone bracelet set on Threads of Faith backer card displaying all four bracelets with inspirational words.
God Is Faithful silicone bracelet set packaged on Threads of Faith backer card showing all four bracelets with inspirational phrases

Threads of Faith Silicone Bracelet Sets from Faithworks

$7.99

Wooden farm tractor playset with trailer, farmer figure, hay bales, horse, and goose—perfect for pretend play and farm adventures.
Wooden farm tractor playset with trailer, farmer figure, hay bales, horse, and goose—perfect for pretend play and farm adventures.

Tender Leaf Toys Wooden Farmyard Tractor

$43.95

Mud Pie MOM Necklace – 16" gold chain with white letter charms, a sweet gift for Mother’s Day or any occasion to celebrate mom.
43% off

Mud Pie Pink “MOM” Necklace

$17.50 $10.00

1 color
The Beaufort Bonnet Pink Smocked Baby Greeting Gown

The Beaufort Bonnet Pink Smocked Baby Greeting Gown

$58.00

1 color, 2 sizes
  • 0-3 months
  • 3-6 months
Mud Pie First Christmas Gown With Hat
Mud Pie First Christmas Boucle Gown With Hat
53% off

Mud Pie First Christmas Gown With Hat

$42.50 $20.00

1 size
  • 0-3 Month
Baby's 1st Christmas Ornament-Adult-Simply Blessed Children's Boutique
50% off

Baby's 1st Christmas Ornament

$15.00 $7.50

Stocking Baby's 1st Christmas Ornament
48% off

Stocking Baby's 1st Christmas Ornament

$19.40 $10.00

Close-up of pink Corolle doll bib with bear design and matching magic milk bottle sized for toddler pretend play.
Corolle doll lying down drinking from the magic baby bottle included in the bib and bottle feeding accessory set.

Bib and Magic Baby Bottle for Corolle Dolls

$15.99

1 color
Gold, white pearl, and pink floral beaded triple layer bracelet set with bow charm shown on model's wrist for styling
Triple layer beaded bracelet set with gold beads, pearls, floral beads, and gold bow charm displayed on soft yellow fabric

Bow Knot Charm Beaded Triple Layer Bracelet Set

$15.99

Cover of My First Bible Stories by Cottage Door Press featuring Noah’s Ark, animals, and trees in a colorful illustrated design
Illustrated Bible storybook spread showing animals, trees, and rivers from the Creation story in My First Bible Stories children’s book

My First Bible Stories Book

$15.99

Magnetic ballet puzzle book with ballerina pieces and scenes—perfect for imaginative play at home or on the go.
Magnetic ballet puzzle book with ballerina pieces and scenes—perfect for imaginative play at home or on the go.

Mud Pie Ballet Magnetic Puzzle Book

$18.50

Kentucky Wildcats kids shirt
Kentucky Wildcats kids shirt – LuLu Bebe Sequin Trim Jersey Top with Wildcat video showing sparkle detail.

LuLu Bebe Sequin Trim Jersey Top with Wildcat

$60.00

1 color, 6 sizes
  • 2T
  • 3T
  • 4T
  • 5
  • 6
  • 7
Fold-out musical prayer book with praying hands cover—plays “Jesus Loves Me” and introduces prayer to little ones.
Fold-out musical prayer book with praying hands cover—plays “Jesus Loves Me” and introduces prayer to little ones.

Mud Pie “Jesus Loves Me” Prayer Book

$25.00

Keepsake Gifts

Accordion list

{"statementLink":"","footerHtml":"","hideMobile":false,"hideTrigger":false,"disableBgProcess":false,"language":"en","position":"right","leadColor":"#4a4a4a","triggerColor":"#4a4a4a","triggerRadius":"50%","triggerPositionX":"right","triggerPositionY":"bottom","triggerIcon":"people","triggerSize":"medium","triggerOffsetX":20,"triggerOffsetY":80,"mobile":{"triggerSize":"small","triggerPositionX":"right","triggerPositionY":"bottom","triggerOffsetX":80,"triggerOffsetY":10,"triggerRadius":"50%"}}
false